Selection of Elders

During my years of voting I have seen it done in 2 ways:

Way One
Vote for one guy or the other: Michael Dukakis OR George Bush

Way Two
Vote on whether the following should be in office:
Judge Johnson Yes No
Judge Smith Yes No
Judge Judy Yes No

At the end of the day, either dukakis OR bush will be in office...
At the end of the day, all 3 judges may be in office... or 2 may be, or 1, or none.

The selection of elders we'll do on Sunday is a "WAY 2" type of voting.